[Intuition, is what she suspects he means. She gets that, too. Her circumstances are unique in that she may sometimes know information that otherwise she shouldn't have. In a way, the fluttering memories or what she thinks must be memories, are something very similar. Recognition in faces, in names, in conversations, in exchanges... Theoretically, those are things she shouldn't experience in this place. Why she does is up for any number of intriguing theories. It's not so different from intuition.

Which is precisely why she doesn't retract her offer. Intuition tells her that he had it for a reason, even if she doesn't yet know what that reason is. Aerith might be the kind to give something without ulterior motive, and she imagines she did the same when it came to him, but she tends to act with purpose.]

I'm getting the feeling I gave it to you. Just because I don't remember why doesn't mean I should take it back. I know what kind of person I am. If I gave it to you, I did it intentionally. Maybe in time, I'll figure out what that reason was for. I think it should stay with you.

[After a moment's consideration, she provides him an easy smile.]

But if you don't want it anymore, I'll keep it.